With its stark angular walls of yellow stone, doors set at odd
angles and bare columns pointing skyward, the memorial center
is intentionally discordant. Visitors feel unsettled, both
by the grim history it relates and the visible architecture.
The Budapest center’s modernist design is partly inspired by
Daniel Liebeskind’s controversial Jewish museum in Berlin. Its
sharp corners
and narrow windows are intentionally jarring, said the museum’s
spokesman, Bálint Molnar. “The Holocaust was an event with no
reason, so we wanted the space to be discordant, and uneasy.”
In that respect, the center is already succeeding. But the wider
process of encouraging and even forcing Hungary to come to terms
with its darkest era, will take longer.
The Holocaust Memorial Center is the first such purpose-built
complex in Central Europe. Built around a restored synagogue on
Pava Street,
in Budapest’s working-class IX district, the HUF 2 billion site
includes exhibition halls, lecture rooms, a library and an archival
research unit. A memorial wall also lists the names of Holocaust
victims. Sixtieth anniversary
The opening took place April 15, the 60th anniversary of the start
of the ghettoization of Hungary’s Jews after the Nazi invasion
in March 1944. Over half a million Hungarian Jews were killed
in the Holocaust. Between May and July 1944, over 437,000 were
deported to Auschwitz. Tens of thousands also died in forced
labor, or were killed by Hungarian Nazi Arrow Cross troopers.
The April 15 opening was also just two weeks before Hungary acceded
the European Union on May 1. Politicians are keen to present
a modern vision of the country as a nation coming to terms with
its
past. Western diplomats have delivered a strong message that
as Hungary joins the EU, it is not acceptable to exploit anti-Semitism
to gain votes.
“For 60 years there has been no debate about the responsibility
of Hungarian society for the Holocaust,” said Molnár. “Under Communism
everything was blamed
on the Germans and a handful of Hungarian extremists. There was no discussion
over the role of the wartime Hungarian authorities, the lack of resistance
and the wholesale looting of Jewish property.”
Governments of both right and left have supported the center.
The former Fidesz government set up the center’s public foundation,
and initiated a Holocaust
Memorial Day. Prime Minister Peter Medgyessy laid the foundation stone in
December 2002.
Writing in Hungary’s conservative daily Magyar Nemzet, former
prime minister Viktor Orbán described the Hungarian Holocaust as
a “wound inflicted on the
heart of the nation,” whose “mortification and shame still lingers.”
Medgyessy attended the center’s opening with President Ferenc
Mádl, Israeli President Moshe Katsav and French Finance Minister
Nicholas Sarkozy, himself
of Hungarian descent.
For some Hungarians the Holocaust remains a purely “Jewish” tragedy.
A recent study even showed that 9 percent of Hungarians had not
even heard about the
Holocaust, while 66 percent do not even know the meaning of the word. The
center aims to change such misperceptions.
“The Holocaust in Hungary was not the private tragedy of the
Jews,” said Molnár. “It is part of Hungarian history, as much as
the revolutions of 1848 or 1956.
Even now it is hard to comprehend the profound damage that has been done
to Hungarian society.” Memorial events
The opening was the centerpiece of a week of events that commemorated
the Holocaust. Hundreds of young people formed a human chain
around the former border of the wartime ghetto, before marching
to the banks of the Danube. Memorial events also took place at
Budapest's Terror House museum, which commemorates the victims
of both Nazism and Communism, in addition to memorial events
at some 50 other sites around the country.
Some among the Jewish community have criticized the Pava Street
location for being in a little-known part of the capital, far
from the main Jewish areas of districts VII and XIII. But the center’s
founders argue that the Pava street synagogue was used as an
internment
camp during 1944 and is an apt choice.
Hungary is home to an estimated 80,000 Jews, the largest community
in the region. Jewish communal life is steadily rebuilding, and
Jews play an active role in the country’s political, economic
and cultural life, at least in Budapest, which boasts several Jewish
schools, cultural and religious organizations.
Works by Nobel laureate and Holocaust survivor Imre Kertész,
author of “Fateless,” are extremely popular and have helped increase
awareness,
especially among the young, on the fate of Hungary’s Jews.
Hungary’s
new Holocaust Memorial Center is the first in Central Europe
Not everyone welcomes the renaissance of Jewish culture. While
the far-right MIEP party, which has been criticized for anti-Semitism,
lost its parliamentary seats in the 2002 election, anti-Semitism
still flourishes among nationalist extremists. The conservative
weekly program “Vasárnapi Újság” on Hungarian state radio has
been criticized for its xenophobic coverage of Jewish issues and
Israeli
investment. MIEP remains an influential force in regional and
local politics. Deep psychic scars
The Holocaust has left deep psychic scars on Hungarian society.
Holocaust survivors still talk of the shock of betrayal, and
the disbelief that their motherland would so readily dispatch
them to their deaths. Hungary’s historical and moral confusion
is perhaps best illustrated by the courtyard of the Museum of
Military History, in Budapest’s Castle District. Two memorials
pay homage to those who lost their lives in World War II: one
to Jewish victims, and another to the viciously anti-Semitic
paramilitary Gendarmes who put them on the trains.
For Holocaust survivors such as Robert Ligeti, the opening is
a long overdue recognition of Hungary’s central role in the deportation
and murder of its own citizens.
“Without the help of the Hungarian authorities the Germans would
not have been able to eliminate the Jews of the countryside,”
Ligeti said. “The Hungarian government drew up the lists of Jews.
The
Hungarian gendarmerie put the Jews in ghettos and on the train
to send them to the camps.”
The worst massacres on Hungarian soil were carried out not by
Germans, but Hungarian Arrow Cross troopers, who, during the winter
of 1944
and 1945, nightly marched dozens of Jews to the banks of the
Danube before shooting them into the water.
Ligeti, 74, a retired child psychologist, vividly remembers the
mocking laughs of his compatriots as the Jews were rounded up
and spat at. “Before that I had always felt that I was Hungarian.
But
when we were marched into the ghetto we were humiliated. People
were standing by the side of the street, laughing at us and making
comments as though we were interesting curiosities.” Failed bomb plot
Two days before the Holocaust Memorial Center opened April 15,
Hungarian counter-terrorist police arrested three men of Arab origin
in Budapest on suspicion of preparing an attack against it. The
alleged ringleader of the plot is a 42-year-old Palestinian dentist,
with Hungarian citizenship, who also served as the Imam of Budapest’s
only mosque in a flat on Bartók Béla Street. Two Syrian nationals
resident in Budapest, acquaintances of the Palestinian dentist,
were detained and questioned as possible witnesses and accomplices.
A Hungarian security service source said: “The
operation was conducted at the highest levels of secrecy. It was
launched in March after
we received a tip-off that a man of Arab origin and member of
the Muslim community was allegedly planning an anti-Jewish terrorist
act involving a bombing in Budapest of a Jewish institution.
The
consequences of this would have been incalculable.”
The Palestinian
dentist was well known in Budapest’s Arab and Muslim community,
about 6,000-strong, for his anti-Israel views,
the official
said. Intelligence officials and police are investigating possible
links to Al-Qaeda, although there is no evidence of such connections
so far.
|