Meanwhile, Visegrad countries remain dependent on non-renewable
energy sources like nuclear power and coal generated energy.
In the Czech kafuffle with Austria, the Austrian Ministry of Environment
pointed out that the Czech Republic already runs an energy surplus,
and thus has little need for the nuclear power plant it currently
runs, called Temelin. People who live near the plant also claim
it is a potential health risk, and are worried the Czech government
will store nuclear waste in their backyards.
Government divided
The Czech government is itself divided over the issue of the plant,
which employs some 1,100 people. Ultimately, it is sending a host
of crossed signals. Last fall, the Industry and Trade Ministry
sided with nuclear energy as the cheapest long-term option in proposing
to build two new nuclear reactors, probably at Temelin, by 2009.
In the same month, Austria's Environment Minister Josef Proell
claimed that Czech Foreign Minister Cyril Svoboda had pledged not
to undertake the planned nuclear expansion during a meeting in
Prague.
CEZ operates the controversial Temelin nuclear plant in the Czech Republic
Svoboda responded quickly. "Under no circumstances is the construction
or expansion of a nuclear power plant on Czech territory being decided
now," he told the Czech News Agency. "The government
has not discussed such a matter. We are trustworthy.” The contentious issue is two active nuclear reactors in Temelin,
some 50 kilometers shy of the Austrian border. For the last 10
years the plant has been the target of cross-border blockades
from environmentalists,
lawsuits from citizens, and even a diplomatic protest from the
Austrian embassy. Czech officials assert that they will continue
talks with
Austria about nuclear expansion, and discuss with its own people
the prospect of local nuclear storage.
Environmentalists protest
In January about 150 protesters from South Bohemia gathered outside
Czech Parliament to protest the proposal to build the nuclear storage
facilities. The government in turn held referendums across the
area to probe public opinion, which showed that a strong majority
of citizens felt negatively about the prospects of nuclear waste
storage in their area. The protests became part of a wider anti-nuclear
movement that spans from South Bohemia to Austrian and German borders.
Dana Kuchtova, of South Bohemian Mothers, a non-governmental organization,
claims that since the Velvet Revolution and systemic changes in
the region there has been a strong anti-nuclear sentiment in Czech
Republic
and Central Europe.
"
We have made blockades and petitions and have tried all forms of
protest. There were even common demonstrations from the Austrian
and Czechs,” said Kuchtova. "Yet these protests bring no discussion
with government."
The construction of Temelin first began in 1986. Czech and Austrian
environmentalists claimed it unsafe because it combined Russian
design with Western fuel and safety technology. Although Temelin
meets and
even exceeds EU safety standards for nuclear power plants, it has
remained controversial.
Kuchtova said that in South Bohemia, many people are more aligned
with Austrian and German environmental approaches, and would
like to see changes in the choices of energy sources, as their
country
remains heavily dependent on coal and nuclear fuels. Neighboring Austria, meanwhile, is a world leader in renewable
energies, with its last nuclear facility closed in 1978. The presence
of a
nuclear plant at its border is an uncomfortable subject. Since
discussion began about Temelin, Austria and environmental groups
like Greenpeace
have made public efforts to denounce nuclear power.
In response, CEZ, the majority-owned government firm that operates
Temelin, launched a massive public relations campaign in the region.
The company spent the equivalent of some EUR 3 million, including
economic support for development of schools and medical facilities.
The company further developed an information center for those interested
in learning about nuclear power. Today this center also provides
online information in German, English and Czech for those interested.
Wanted: Cheap energy fast
The core of the issue is that the Czech government is scrambling
to find a cost-effective solution as the country prepares to close
down most of its brown coal plants to adhere to EU green policies.
In making these moves, and to avoid a shock on the local economy,
one alternative proposed was to build two new reactors at Temelin
to meet supply targets by 2009.
Nuclear energy accounts for one-third of the country's electricity
and 17 percent of its total energy needs. The country's operating
nuclear plants, Temelin and Dukovany, in South Moravia are the
sole providers. The rest of Czech energy mainly comes from fossil
fuels
(coal and oil).
Dukovany is to be closed by 2027, and CEZ plans to reduce coal
production in 2010 as its older plants will be offline. The Czech
Industry and
Trade Ministry predicts domestic coal supplies will be depleted
by 2060. Milan Nebesar, a spokesperson for the Temelin nuclear
power
facility said there is some small-scale research in renewable
energy sources like solar and wind power. He maintains, however,
that
the focus of CEZ is to upgrade their existing coal plants.
"
We will see what is developing in new energetics, but first we will
evaluate the proposals of the Czech government," Nebesar
said.
The Czech government owns 67 percent of CEZ and largely
determines
how it operates. While the Temelin nuclear plant is CEZ’s most-known
energy plant, the bulk of its power is drawn from coal. Yet by
2015 many of its coal-burning power stations will close and must
be replaced.
The conundrum of the company is how to cope with growing energy
demands and remain profitable.
The Czech Ministry of Trade supports additional nuclear power,
while environment ministry wants current levels maintained. In
January,
the Czech government buckled on its pro-nuclear position by delaying
a vote for nuclear expansion for two months so it can proceed
with more talks with Austria. Milan Nebesar does not deny that
CEZ has
an energy surplus, but he explains it is the situation for those
in energetics who must deal with pending coal plant closures
and growing energy needs.
"
We have some exports, yes, quite a lot,” he said. "Nowadays
that is the situation because we have to modernize energetics
in the next four years, and we will need more power.’’
While CEZ does not expect to penetrate the Austrian energy market,
with its energy surplus CEZ could take advantage of the EU’s
plan for full liberalization of the electricity market in 2007.
CEZ
wants to be a leading energy exporter in Eastern Europe. It
has active
tenders for a number of energy plants that are being privatized
in Slovakia and Bulgaria. The company also has further long-term
plans
to enter the Hungarian and Polish markets.
According to Reuters news agency, a spokesperson with the Czech
government said a vote for nuclear expansion will be delayed
until March. Deputy
Industry and Trade Minister Martin Pecina, who prepared the
2004-2030 energy policy draft, said the government planned
to hold a seminar
and talks with anti-nuclear neighbor Austria. This all occurs
while the Czech government is preparing for EU accession
in May. With
more talks planned, the issue will likely be buried until
another protest
is launched - probably in time for ceremonies in Brussels.
Nuclear Energy in Visegrád Nations
Czech
republic
The Czech Republic has two nuclear power plants, Dukovany and Temelin.
After years of delay, on Oct. 9, 2000, the Czech Nuclear Safety
Authority cleared Temelín for operation, located only 37 miles
from the Austrian border. The first reactor was connected to the
national grid in December 2000. The reactor has been shut down
a number of times due to technical problems, all while posing no
health risks. The second unit of the Czech Temelín nuclear power
plant was put into trial operation on April 18, 2003. Nuclear power
currently generates 30 percent of Czech electricity.
Slovak republic
Slovakia has two nuclear power plants, which generated an estimated
54 percent of Slovakia's electricity in 2001. The Jaslovske Bohunice
plant at Trnava has four, 408-MW reactors that are functioning,
and one decommissioned reactor. The plant's two older reactors
are due
to be decommissioned in 2006 and 2008 as part of the energy chapter
of Slovakia's accession agreement with the EU. The Mochovce plant
has two 412-MW reactors in operation and two uncompleted reactors.
Construction of these reactors has been halted, as government financial
support for them has ended.
HUNGARY
The PAKS nuclear power plant in Hungary consists of four, Soviet-designed,
second generation VVER-440/213 reactor units. There are plans
not only to expand generation capacity of the reactors by 8 percent,
but to extend the life cycle of the reactor units by 20 years.
The normal lifespan of the four units ends between 2012 and 2017.
In
order to ensure continuous operation of the plant, the necessary
modernization improvements would have to begin in 2007. On April
10, 2003, some fuel rods in Unit 2 were damaged, causing a radioactive
gas leak. According to reports, the leak constituted no threat
to the environment, but the incident could result in major financial
losses to the company.
POLAND
The Republic of Poland has no nuclear energy production, however
it does have significant coal resources of high quality. In
fact, the Polish power sector is the largest in Central Europe
and
Poland is one of the most coal dependent countries in the world.
Electricity
generation in Poland is predominantly coal-based. Coal accounts
for 97 percent of all electric power produced, the remaining
three percent
coming from hydroelectric facilities.
Sources: Energy Information
Administration and US Department of Fossil Energy
|