But
trying to convince wine buyers abroad to choose Hungarian wine
is a more difficult task. Especially when they have access
to better-known French, Italian, Australian, or American varieties.
“Is
there such a thing as Hungarian wine?” clients sometimes ask
Monika Elling, chief marketing officer at Monarchia Matt International
(MMI), when she pulls out her portfolio of high-end, limited-production
Hungarian wines.
“A lot of people in America have never heard of it, and don’t
think of Hungary as a wine producer. In fact, they don’t think
much about Hungary at all,” she said. “So, the country has an image
issue to overcome.” MMI, a Hungarian-American firm which makes
and distributes high-end, artisan-style wine, is leading the way
in educating and re-introducing the world to fine Hungarian wines.
They have earned a reputation for being the ambassadors of Hungarian
wine to America.
Hungary’s image problem
Not only does Hungary have an image problem to overcome, but it
lags far behind its international competitors in marketing its
wine and image as a wine making country. The problem in the Hungarian
wine industry is no longer with the product, as it was during the
Communist-era of mass-producing wine factories. Hungarian wines
are being increasingly praised internationally. In the past two
years, for example, they have won top prizes in competitions in
Japan, Canada, Germany, France, Belgium, England, Argentina, Switzerland,
Italy, Spain, Brazil, The United States, Slovenia, and Slovakia.
Still, the average consumer abroad knows little about Hungarian
wine.
“We have 2,000 years of wine making history, and we just had a
few bad decades,” said Attila Sándor, a wine educator and wine
tour-guide based in Budapest.
“The problem is that the generation that is now our potential
clientele grew up during those decades when Hungary wasn’t mentioned
over the dinner table as a wine making country.”
Clearly, Hungary needs to develop a strategy for promoting its
wines and establishing an international image as a quality wine
producer. Where’s the Government?
“I always felt that Hungary needed a flagship image that it could
offer the world, and in my mind, the sexiest thing that Hungary
could offer was great wine,” said Elling, who has been pushing
this idea to the government since the early 1990’s.
“It has all of the things you need — great territory, a terrific
history, great personalities. It has the potential for great wines,
and frankly you don’t need to speak Hungarian to drink a bottle
of Hungarian wine.”
Wine never did become Hungary’s flagship image, and unlike most
other successful wine producing countries, Hungary doesn’t have
a dedicated wine marketing organization to push its cause. Katalin
Bencze, the project manager responsible for wine marketing at the
Hungarian Agricultural Marketing Center (AMC), blames it on a lack
of money. The AMC cannot move forward with a more aggressive marketing
campaign because, “we have a very limited budget. With such little
money, we can do few things.”
Winemakers are disappointed with what they say is a lack of support
from the government, and according to Elling it’s more difficult
for winemakers to get financial support like bank loans. Hungarian
winemakers also aren’t able to contribute financially to marketing
campaigns, like MMI’s wineries from other countries do.
Tax system volatility
“It’s surprising I’m still alive,” said Szekszárd wine producer
Ferenc Takler, about his winery. According to him, the government
changes the tax system too often.“ In spite of the government’s
effort, Hungarian wine has an improving image,” said Takler, who
is last year’s Hungarian Winemaker of the Year (a prize awarded
by the Hungarian Wine Academy). Takler has also become one of MMI’s
star winemakers.
“He has developed a following in America,” said Elling. “And there
are people who look for the next Takler wine.”
Steps are being taken by the government, said Bencze, in the creation
of a new Hungarian national wine marketing board being planned
for later this year. Currently the AMC, which falls under the banner
of the Ministry of Agriculture and Regional Development, is responsible
for marketing wine, as well as Hungary’s other agricultural products.
The new board would take over the marketing responsibilities from
the AMC, and would be financed partially by the government, with
contributions from the wine producers, she explained. It is being
formed with the cooperation of four Hungarian wine groups (the
Hungarian Wine Academy, the Guild of Pannonian Vintners, the National
Council of Wine Communities and the Hungarian Wine Association).
According to Sándor, the creation of the new organization is also
a result of the pressure which these groups have been putting on
the government.
A joint effort
“At first much of the money would have to come from the bigger
producers, rather than the small family companies,” said Bencze.
“But we would like it to operate like the German Wine Institute
or the French Sopexa, which also get money from the wine producers.”
Currently, the AMC’s main means of support for winemakers is funding
their participation in four annual international wine festivals.
Hungary produces four million hectoliters of wine a year (less
than Chile and Australia, but more than Austria and New Zealand)
and in 2003, it exported about twenty percent of that, according
to the National Council of Wine Communities. According to the organization,
Hungary exported USD 76.2 million worth of wine in that year.
MMI, however, is banking on the idea the American market will
become the most important. According to the National Council of
Wine Communities, Hungary exports ? HUF of wine every year. Although
sales within Hungary account for most of the wine sales, “the foreign
market is of utmost importance. We’re not only speaking about selling
wine, but what we sell abroad should also generate wine tourism
to sustain the wine regions,” said Sándor, who has been in the
tourism business for more than 20 years. “What Hungary needs to
do is to represent itself with top quality wines to the best restaurants
and wine shops in the world, to raise eyebrows, and to generate
the interest of connoisseurs, which will make them want to visit
the country,” he said. “We can’t feed the world with wines, but
we can attract them with wine. We can educate the world about our
wines, and they will learn about our culture. Hungary is an old
world wine producer with both old and new world style.”
The Bikavér Problem
One of Hungary’s biggest obstacles, say observers, is overcoming
past marketing mistakes that have sullied its reputation. Egri
Bikavér made its name abroad in the 1970’s when it was mass produced
and exported, usually ending up on the bottom shelf of American
and British supermarkets. Besides a few bottles of pricey Tokaj,
these sub-par Bikavérs (made from grapes that didn’t make the cut
for superior wines) were the only Hungarian wine available in the
United States until recently (Egervin Bikavér is still sold in
the US for USD 3.99-6.99 a bottle).
The problem was that the name Bikavér became associated with cheap,
acidic wine. But Bikavér—a cuvee of three or more grape varieties,
made in both Eger and Szekszárd—can be a great wine, and many of
today’s Bikavérs are exceptionally different than those of the
past. Some of Hungary’s best winemakers—Tibor Gál, Ferenc Takler,
Vilmos Thummerer, and Ferenc Vesztergombi, are successfully producing
quality Bikavérs.
“There’s so much turmoil on the Hungarian market about this one
issue, about what Bikavér means,” said Elling. “Is it from Eger
or Szekszárd, its concept, its marketability outside of Hungary.
My point is that there’s no point to this discussion because its
fate has essentially been sealed by the fact that there’s only
one type of Bikavér that’s commercially viable on export markets
across the world, and that’s essentially called Egri Bikavér, and
it’s inexpensive. The problem is that if you’re trying to sell
with the same name another product that’s five times the price,
without some serious marketing, then it’s impossible.”
MMI recently gambled on adding Takler’s Szekszárdi Bikavér Reserve
2002 to its portfolio. “We have been able to achieve something
that Hungary as a country has yet to accomplish, and that is to
put out a high end Bikavér in America at the USD 22 price point,
which is USD 60-75 in restaurants. We’re not going to flood the
market with Bikavérs, but we definitely made a breakthrough and
we feel very comfortable that our wines regardless of what they
are called are known for the quality that they deliver.”
MMI also sells Takler’s Cabernet Franc 2003 for USD 90, which
is a price almost unheard of for a non-Tokaj Hungarian wine. Another
Bikavér, Tibor Gál’s Egri Bikavér is also sold in the US through
Kobrand, a New York-based wine importer which also co-owns Gál’s
winery.
Elling compares the Bikavér problem to what Tuscany went through
with Chianti, which used to be sold in ubiquitously cheap, straw-covered
bottles. In the 1970s Tuscan winemakers began re-inventing their
wines, creating pricey Super Tuscans, which brought prestige back
to the region.
“All of a sudden the region and wine’s whole image has been restored,
but it cost Italy an arm and a leg to do so,” said Elling.
“The question is: is Hungary prepared to do that? There needs
to be a plan, and Hungary doesn’t have a plan.”
Starting from the beginning
Marketing Hungarian wine requires more patience than marketing
the wines of countries like Italy, Spain, and France, which have
already firmly established reputations and images for themselves,
and it can’t be assumed that people know anything about Hungarian
wine.
“We see ourselves to a great extent as educators too,” said Elling.
“And its actually exciting for me to be able to tell them a new
story, a story that they will believe, and a story that they will
fall in love with.”
MMI, which is run by Nimrod Kovacs (former head of UPC Hungary),
has brought Hungarian wines to the wine lists of a few of New York’s
finest restaurants, like Café des Artistes (owned by Gundel’s George
Lang), Chanterelle (winner of multiple James Beard awards) and
Danube (run by award-winning chef David Bouley), and to wine retail
stores along the east coast, with plans of continuing to spread
further.
MMI places a high importance on providing a good price-value ratio,
since inappropriate pricing is a problem among Hungarian winemakers,
noted Elling.
“In order to communicate wine abroad you have to be familiar with
a nation’s wine taste,” said Sandor. Most tourists who take Sandor’s
wine tours have just superficial knowledge about Hungarian wine.
“They know just about as much as Tokaj as they do about Cuban cigars,”
he added. When meeting foreign clients, he emphasizes careful attention
must be paid to different cultural preferences and attitudes.
Germans, for example, are especially interested in those types
of Hungarian wines made by winemakers who have German roots. According
to Sandor, Tokaj is a misconception that needs to be corrected.
“Only five percent of wine from Tokaj is sweet, and from that only
one percent is essencia,” he said. “It’s a pity for us and for
them that they only see that one percent.”
There has been rising demand recently in the US and the UK for
artisan style products — high quality, hand crafted, limited products
by small producers. This is exactly what Hungarians say their “new
generation” of winemakers create, and it could potentially bring
large success abroad.
“It’s hard to enter any new market, but Hungarian wine earned
a good reputation in whichever markets that it entered,” said Takler.
“The reputation is continually improving with the quality of winemaking
in Hungary, especially considering that we had to start from zero.
Outside of Hungary it’s not the connections that count, but the
quality of the wine.” |